Every year, Christmas adverts offer a slice of consumerist comfort to people curled up in front of a screen. Increasingly, some of those ads are produced with artificial intelligence, and the strategy has repeatedly backfired. The reason is not only ethical. It is also philosophical, and it explains why audiences react so strongly, even when they cannot say exactly what feels wrong.
Concealment is where the backlash begins
The pattern is now familiar. In the Netherlands, McDonald’s pulled an AI-generated Christmas ad that showed chaotic holiday mishaps after just three days, following fierce backlash over the fact that the AI usage had not been disclosed. Coca-Cola’s 2025 festive campaign drew similar criticism, with AI-generated scenery and animals that many viewers found uncanny.
The rules differ depending on where you live. The EU now restricts this kind of omission through new transparency rules governing how AI-generated content is labelled. UK law does not require on-screen disclosure, so brands including Very and Plusnet have pressed ahead, often placing the information in separate press releases and trade announcements rather than telling viewers directly. The UK Advertising Standards Authority still prohibits misleading omissions when an advert falsely implies human creation in order to deceive consumers.
Even subtle uses can stir unease. Royal Mail’s 2025 Christmas ad relied on traditional live-action footage, but it later emerged that an AI voiceover narrated it. That detail matters because replacing human performers, even behind the microphone, feeds a wider anxiety among industry insiders and the public, echoing the fears behind the 2023 Hollywood writers’ and actors’ strikes.
The Dior case: suspicion without proof
The most revealing example may be one where AI probably was not the issue. Dior’s Christmas short film was described as hand-drawn and directed by the French animator Sylvain Chomet, with a cast including Rihanna and Robert Pattinson. It follows the friendship between the designer Christian Dior and the film star Marlene Dietrich. Commenters praised its authentic look, and Dior published a behind-the-scenes page showing the actors and design sketches.
Some viewers were unconvinced. Garbled hands and fingers are a well-known sign of AI-generated imagery, and some pointed to what they perceived as missing fingers and strange hand transitions. In an interview with Variety, Chomet and producer Aton Soumache insisted that generative AI was never used. They did confirm using “automated interpolation” to generate intermediate frames, describing it as a very small part of the process, handling the repetitive, mechanical side of animation rather than the creative work. It is a standard digital animation tool that predates AI, though it now often involves it.
This is the larger story. Just as deepfakes risk undermining trust in all images online, a few undisclosed AI-produced ads can make viewers suspicious of all advertising. Audiences start hunting for evidence of brands cutting corners rather than hiring creatives, and even unfounded accusations leave a mark.
What forgery teaches us about feeling cold
Here is the part most coverage misses. The coldness is not just about quality. Philosophers of art argue that forgeries are worse as artworks because they misrepresent achievement. We normally appreciate what an artist did in making a work. When a painting turns out not to be a genuine Vermeer but a 20th-century forgery by Van Meegeren, we judge it differently, even though the image itself has not changed.
The same logic applies to a beautiful animated Christmas ad. If it is presented as delicate hand animation but was generated through raw computational power, the appearance of craft becomes a façade. It is not fraud, but it diminishes the experience. Using AI to help build complex scenery can involve real skill, and some philosophers liken it to gardening. Yet it is not the process of hand-drawing and animation, and presenting it as such imitates a style without the labour behind it.
There is an irony here too. Major brands balking at the tedious task of getting the details right, while giving the impression of fully human creation, is the kind of moral defect that can sour our aesthetic response. The wider ethical questions add weight: AI models are often trained on artists’ work without compensation, they threaten to put artists out of work, and AI datacentres affect communities and the environment.
The brands answering with visible craft
Some companies have responded by showing their human processes. Prada’s campaign emphasises traditional hand-drawn animation, with a separate behind-the-scenes video highlighting its artists. Barbour and Thatchers Cider each employed Aardman, the producers of Wallace & Gromit, to hand-animate their adverts. Etsy’s festive campaign is titled “celebrate being human”, and some video game studios have detailed their refusal to use generative AI.
The praise these productions receive suggests audiences still care deeply about craft. This points to a practical lesson for any organisation using AI in creative work: the technology can support skilled people, but the value audiences attach to a piece often rests on knowing what human effort stood behind it. Honest disclosure is not just regulatory caution. It protects the thing viewers are actually responding to.
In short
Audiences feel cold toward AI Christmas ads largely because undisclosed AI use can misrepresent who, or what, did the work, and philosophers of art have long argued that misrepresented achievement makes a work feel lesser, as with a forgery. The backlash to McDonald’s and Coca-Cola, and the suspicion that fell even on Dior’s hand-drawn film, show how quickly trust erodes when disclosure is missing. Brands such as Prada, Barbour, Thatchers Cider and Etsy have instead made human craft visible, and audiences have rewarded them. The lesson is that transparency about how something was made is part of the creative experience itself.
Based on reporting from The Conversation.